← Insights·Private Equity & Venture Capital

Replace the Portfolio Company CEO? Diagnose the System First

Diagnose the missed plan, the job ahead and the commitments the sponsor still owes.

By Ken Gavranovic · October 29, 2026

Your portfolio company has missed plan twice. The board is discussing a new CEO, and as the operating partner, you're being asked whether to support the change.

You know the CEO's forecast and how they explain the miss. You may know much less about the decisions, handoffs and resource constraints behind it.

Before recommending replacement, I'd ask what a new CEO would actually change, and why the current one can't.

A leadership change can be necessary. It can also consume time without removing the obstacle. If the next person inherits the same unfunded commitments and unresolved decisions, you haven't finished the job by filling the seat.

I would diagnose the operating system before settling the talent verdict. But system-first doesn't mean the CEO gets a pass. Building and changing that system may be the work you hired them to do.

Name the miss against the investment case

Start with the three to five changes carrying the value creation plan, not a general judgment that the team lacks urgency. Perhaps the deal depends on raising realized prices, expanding into enterprise accounts or reducing delivery costs. For each move, write the result expected by now, what actually happened and the operating evidence behind the difference.

Then test the plan itself. Did customers reject the offer? Did the economics change? Did the investment case leave out work the business needed? A leader can execute a flawed thesis diligently.

Keep external causes separate from internal constraints. A market contraction or the loss of a major customer's budget may explain part of the shortfall. A chair who knows the customers and the business can make a sound case for backing the CEO through that disruption. That support still needs a credible response from management; it isn't a promise that the original plan will recover.

Also separate the event from the response. The CEO may not control the shock. You can assess how early they surfaced it, what options they brought and what they changed.

Find the constraint, and who can change it

Choose the missed move that matters most to the investment case. Trace recent work behind it with the people responsible, using actual decisions and records rather than the board deck alone. Check who can approve the necessary tradeoffs, whether functions pass usable information to each other, whether the data can support the call and what the incentives reward.

Suppose the growth thesis requires enterprise sales, but deals keep failing technical validation. The CRO may need better qualification. Product may lack a required capability. Or the sponsor may have underwritten the revenue while declining to fund the engineering work it depends on. Those explanations call for different remedies.

Ask what the executive has already done about the obstacle. Did they identify it, propose a workable tradeoff and escalate it to someone with authority? Or did they leave it unresolved and keep forecasting the same result? A constraint outside someone's authority and a constraint they won't confront are different evidence about their performance.

Put the sponsor's commitments in the review too. If the investment case assumed help from a pricing specialist or an operating team, was that help actually available? Promised portfolio support is not delivered capacity.

Share the specific gaps with management and let them challenge the diagnosis. They may reveal a real constraint you missed. Agree what they will change and what requires a sponsor or board decision. Keep individual assessments confidential; openness about the work doesn't require circulating personnel judgments.

Test a repair without taking over

If the evidence is mixed and the company has room to learn, agree a bounded operating change with the incumbent. In the enterprise-sales example, that might mean tightening qualification and allocating capacity to the specific technical gap, with a clear owner for each. Decide what you should see before revenue arrives, such as qualified opportunities completing technical validation, and when a commercial result should follow. Compare like opportunities where possible rather than celebrating one convenient win.

Look at both the work and the executive's contribution. Did the leader make the difficult allocation, secure cooperation and follow through? A plan they present confidently is not the same as capability they've demonstrated.

The operating partner can bring expertise and remove a sponsor-side obstacle. Be explicit about where that help ends. If your team quietly takes over the executive's job, improved results tell you less about whether the executive can run the business after you leave.

Don't treat the repair as a controlled experiment. Several things may change at once, and results can lag. Improvement doesn't establish that the leader was blameless; continued underperformance doesn't isolate the leader as the cause.

This is a proposed decision practice, not a validated test of executive ability or a promise of better returns.

Give the review a deadline

The check needs a clock. Set the decision date when you open the review, based on cash, customer exposure and how quickly useful evidence can arrive. A long expected hold doesn't make delay free. A short one doesn't make a rushed replacement wise.

Where evidence already shows that the executive can't or won't make the required changes, system repair and replacement can proceed together. Serious integrity or safety concerns need prompt handling through the appropriate process, not a diagnostic grace period.

For an acquisition or a new appointment, a roughly 100-day checkpoint can help organize early operating commitments. It isn't a universal deadline for proving that a leader can scale. A long sales cycle may not produce revenue by then, but you should still know whether agreed decisions and milestones happened. Establish expectations at the start, while leaving room to revise assumptions with management.

During the review, use a short weekly check on work that can move weekly. Reuse reliable operating data and automate routine reporting where useful. Don't commission another reporting burden to prove that people are busy.

At the decision date, an extension needs a reason: what new evidence will arrive, by when, and why is it worth the cost of waiting?

Decide who can do the next job

The board's choice may be to back the incumbent with specific support, add a missing capability, change responsibilities or appoint a different leader. If the thesis no longer holds, revising it belongs in the same discussion. Replacing the CEO is not a substitute for admitting that the investment plan needs to change.

Compare realistic alternatives. What can the incumbent deliver with agreed support? What would an available successor bring, how long would the transition take, and which constraints would remain? Don't compare the executive you know with an imaginary candidate who has every strength and no dependencies.

A change can be justified even when the current CEO didn't cause the miss. The company may now need a turnaround leader, an integration leader or a different commercial capability. The question is fitness for the work ahead, not whether you can make one person responsible for every disappointing number.

If replacement is the answer, carry the diagnosis into the search brief: the outcomes, the repairs the new leader must lead, and the authority and support you will provide. Before approving the appointment, ask one final question: which obstacle will this person be better equipped to remove, and which decision still belongs to us?

Frequently asked questions

Should we replace our portfolio company CEO after missing plan?

Diagnose the operating system before settling the talent verdict, because a leadership change can be necessary but it can also consume time without removing the obstacle, and if the next person inherits the same unfunded commitments and unresolved decisions, you haven't finished the job by filling the seat. System-first doesn't mean the CEO gets a pass, since building and changing that system may be the work you hired them to do. A change can be justified even when the current CEO didn't cause the miss, because the question is fitness for the work ahead, so compare what the incumbent could deliver with agreed support against what an available successor would actually bring, how long a transition would take and which constraints would remain.

How do I figure out what actually caused the miss before judging the CEO?

Start with the three to five changes carrying the value creation plan, not a general judgment that the team lacks urgency, and for each move write down the result expected by now, what actually happened and the operating evidence behind the difference. Then test the plan itself, since a leader can execute a flawed thesis diligently: ask whether customers rejected the offer, whether the economics changed, or whether the investment case left out work the business needed. Keep external causes like a market contraction or the loss of a major customer's budget separate from internal constraints, and judge the event separately from the response: the CEO may not control the shock, but you can still assess how early they surfaced it, what options they brought and what they changed.

How can I tell whether the CEO is blocked by something outside their control or just not confronting it?

Trace the recent work behind the missed move that matters most to the investment case with the people responsible, using actual decisions and records rather than the board deck alone, and check who can approve the necessary tradeoffs, whether functions pass usable information to each other, whether the data can support the call and what the incentives reward. Then ask whether the executive identified the obstacle, proposed a workable tradeoff and escalated it to someone with authority, or left it unresolved and kept forecasting the same result, because a constraint outside someone's authority and a constraint they won't confront are different evidence about their performance. Put the sponsor's commitments in the review too: if the investment case assumed help like a pricing specialist or an operating team, check whether that help was actually available, because promised portfolio support is not delivered capacity.

Should we try a repair with the current CEO before deciding to replace them?

Yes, if the evidence is mixed and the company has room to learn: agree on a bounded operating change with the incumbent, for example tightening deal qualification and allocating capacity to a specific technical gap, with a clear owner for each piece. Decide up front what you should see before revenue arrives, such as qualified opportunities completing technical validation, and when a commercial result should follow, and compare like opportunities where possible rather than celebrating one convenient win. The operating partner can bring expertise and remove a sponsor-side obstacle, but be explicit about where that help ends, because if your team quietly takes over the executive's job, improved results tell you less about whether the executive can run the business after you leave.

Does a successful repair prove the CEO can do the job?

No, because the repair isn't a controlled experiment: several things may change at once and results can lag, so improvement doesn't establish that the leader was blameless, and continued underperformance doesn't isolate the leader as the cause. Look at both the work and the executive's contribution, whether they made the difficult allocation, secured cooperation and followed through, since a plan they present confidently is not the same as capability they've demonstrated. Treat the whole approach as a proposed decision practice, not a validated test of executive ability or a promise of better returns.

How long should the review run before we have to decide?

Set the decision date when you open the review, based on cash, customer exposure and how quickly useful evidence can arrive, because a long expected hold doesn't make delay free and a short one doesn't make a rushed replacement wise. During the review, use a short weekly check on work that can move weekly, reusing reliable operating data and automating routine reporting where useful, and at the decision date an extension needs a reason: what new evidence will arrive, by when, and why it's worth the cost of waiting. Where evidence already shows the executive can't or won't make the required changes, system repair and replacement can proceed together, and serious integrity or safety concerns need prompt handling through the appropriate process, not a diagnostic grace period.

Is a 100-day checkpoint the right deadline for a new CEO?

A roughly 100-day checkpoint can help organize early operating commitments for an acquisition or a new appointment, but it isn't a universal deadline for proving that a leader can scale. A long sales cycle may not produce revenue by then, but you should still know whether agreed decisions and milestones happened. Establish expectations at the start, while leaving room to revise assumptions with management.

What should the search brief say if we do decide to replace the CEO?

Carry the diagnosis into the search brief: the outcomes, the repairs the new leader must lead, and the authority and support you will provide. Before approving the appointment, ask which obstacle this person will be better equipped to remove, and which decision still belongs to you. If the thesis no longer holds, revising it belongs in the same discussion, because replacing the CEO is not a substitute for admitting that the investment plan needs to change.

Keep reading

Work with KenMore insights